Interview questions by type

Civil Service Making Effective Decisions: interview questions and examples

Making Effective Decisions is the Success Profiles behaviour about using evidence and knowledge to make sound, timely decisions: gathering the right information, weighing the options and risks, consulting the right people, and being able to explain why you chose what you did.

A strong example shows a real decision that was yours to make, the evidence you used, the alternatives you rejected and why, and what happened as a result. Panels care about your reasoning as much as the outcome.

Mock Interview Copilot practice room: an AI interviewer asks a follow-up question while the candidate's spoken answer and pace appear in the transcript
Practising answers out loud in Mock Interview Copilot: the interviewer follows up when an answer is vague, and your pace and pauses are measured.

How it is assessed, and how it changes by grade

Many adverts ask for a written statement on Making Effective Decisions, often about 250 words; the advert says how many words. At interview, you will be asked about a decision you made, and the panel scores your answer against a scale for the grade.

The Success Profiles framework describes each behaviour at levels: Level 1 broadly AA/AO, Level 2 EO, Level 3 HEO/SEO, Level 4 Grade 7/6, Level 5 the Senior Civil Service. At AA/AO, it means making decisions within your remit, checking facts and knowing when to refer something up. At EO, panels look for gathering information from several sources, weighing options, consulting others and explaining your choice. At HEO/SEO, decisions have wider impact: complex or incomplete evidence, risks to assess, and stakeholders to involve. At Grade 7/6, decisions carry significant consequences, often under uncertainty and with competing priorities.

Interview questions on Making Effective Decisions, and what the panel is looking for

  1. Tell me about a decision you made using data or evidence.

    What the panel is looking for: What evidence you gathered, how you judged whether it was reliable, and how it shaped the decision.

  2. Describe a time you had to make a decision without all the information you wanted.

    What the panel is looking for: That you were clear about what you did not know, made a reasonable judgement in time, and built in a way to review it.

  3. Give an example of a difficult decision that not everyone agreed with.

    What the panel is looking for: That you listened to other views, explained your reasoning openly and stood by a sound decision, or changed it for a good reason.

  4. Tell me about a time you had to choose between several options.

    What the panel is looking for: That you set out the options, weighed costs, risks and benefits, and can say why the others were rejected.

  5. Describe a decision you made that turned out to be wrong.

    What the panel is looking for: Honesty, how quickly you noticed, how you put it right, and what you changed in how you decide.

  6. For EO posts: tell me about a time you knew a decision was not yours to make.

    What the panel is looking for: Judgement about your remit: gathering the facts, then referring up with a clear recommendation.

  7. For HEO/SEO posts: tell me about a decision that affected people outside your team.

    What the panel is looking for: That you identified who would be affected, consulted them, considered the risks and recorded your rationale.

  8. For Grade 7 posts: describe a decision you made under uncertainty with significant consequences.

    What the panel is looking for: How you balanced competing priorities, used expert advice, managed risk and communicated the decision.

How to build a Making Effective Decisions example with STAR

Choose a decision that was genuinely yours, with more than one sensible option. The panel scores the quality of your thinking, so the Action section should walk through your reasoning, not just what you did. Pitch it to the grade: a choice about your own work suits AO or EO; a decision affecting others suits HEO and above.

Example answer

Tell me about a decision you made using evidence.

Situation: I was a booking coordinator in an NHS hospital's outpatient department. A consultant went on unexpected long-term leave, and around 150 patients were booked into her clinics over the next eight weeks.

Task: my manager asked me to decide how to rebook them, within the rules of our access policy, and to bring her a plan within two days.

Action: I listed the options: move everyone to the next available clinics in date order, offer appointments with other consultants, or ask the clinical team to review the list and prioritise. I pulled each patient's referral date and priority code, and found that about 30 were urgent or close to their waiting time limit. I checked with the service manager which other consultants could take extra patients, and asked a senior nurse to confirm that urgent patients could safely see a different consultant. I rejected straight date order because it would have delayed some urgent patients. My recommendation was to offer urgent patients the first available slots with any suitable consultant, and rebook routine patients in date order. I wrote down the reasoning so it could be checked later.

Result: my manager approved the plan the same day. All urgent patients were seen within their target time, and we had only a handful of complaints, which were from routine patients and resolved by phone. The approach was reused when another clinic was cancelled later that year.

Example 250-word statement

Written for an AO or EO application

As a duty manager at a 90-room hotel, I was in charge one evening when our booking system double-booked eight rooms because of a fault with an online travel agent. Eight guests were due to arrive with nowhere to stay.

I had to decide quickly how to handle it. I checked the system to confirm exactly which bookings clashed and how many rooms we had free, which was three. I then considered the options: upgrading three guests to our suites, moving guests to a partner hotel nearby, or contacting the travel agent to cancel the duplicate bookings. Cancelling was not fair to guests who had paid in good faith, so I ruled it out.

I phoned our partner hotel and confirmed five rooms at a similar standard. I used the bookings to decide who stayed with us: guests with children and one guest with mobility needs were kept on site, because moving them would cause the most disruption. I agreed with the general manager by phone that we would pay for the partner rooms and a taxi, then called each guest before arrival to explain.

All eight guests had a room that night, none cancelled their future bookings, and two left positive reviews about how it was handled. I recorded the decision and costs for the general manager, and we changed how we reconcile online bookings each afternoon.

Mistakes to avoid

Frequently asked questions

What is a good Making Effective Decisions example?

A real decision you were responsible for, with at least two sensible options. Explain the evidence you used, who you consulted, the risks, why you chose one option over the others, and what happened.

How is Making Effective Decisions different at EO and HEO?

At EO, panels look for gathering information, weighing options and explaining a decision within your area. At HEO, decisions usually affect others, involve less complete evidence and need you to assess risks and consult stakeholders.

How do I write a 250-word Making Effective Decisions statement?

Use one STAR example and spend most of the words on your reasoning: the evidence, the options and why you chose one. Finish with the result and what you learned. The advert gives the exact word limit.

Can I use a decision that went wrong?

Yes, if your reasoning was sound at the time and you show how you noticed, put it right and changed your approach. Avoid examples where the decision was careless.